Musical.ly vs Vine: Apps Comparison

Musical.ly and Vine

Short videos are increasingly popular on the Web today. We live in a world where nobody has five minutes, or even a minute, to watch something as inane as a funny or touching video. Sure, we still have attention span for television shows, and even for binge watching, but we don’t want to waste time with our short entertainment – it’s got to be really short. Vine and Musical.ly are only two of the growing niche of short video makers that help you provide entertainment for others with mandatory time limits imposed upon you.

Vine vs Musical.ly Differences and Similarities

Vine and Musical.ly are both, at heart, essentially the same type of service: the sort that allows you to make short videos for your friends and followers. Both are social networks, with a lot of friend features and sharing options. If you’ve made a video you really like, it’s easy to put it on Facebook, Twitter, or Tumblr. You can add friends, watch their videos, and comment with ease. Both apps began on the iOS platform and migrated eventually to Android, so they’re both a touch weaker on Android systems.

Despite these many similarities, however, there are some pretty significant differences between the two apps. Namely, their purpose. Vine is all about short videos of all kinds, whether it’s comedy, music, or anything else. By contrast, Musical.ly is focused on music videos. Their scope, thus, is quite different.

Vine Pros and Cons

vine vs musical ly apps battle review

Vine is a popular app, but everything has its ups and downs.

Its strengths are:

  • General content: Anything can be a Vine as long as it’s short enough! You choose the content.
  • Super easy to use: Signing up and using Vine is a breeze. Basically anyone can do it – you can sign up easily with your Twitter account and get going.
  • Very little time per video: For our quick-moving world, Vine offers the option of bite-sized entertainment. No wasting times watching terrible Vines – if they’re bad, you’ve only missed six seconds.

Its weaknesses are:

  • No filters: You can’t edit the video to look pretty very much, and there are no preset filters.
  • Autoplay: The app automatically plays sound, which can be super annoying as you scroll down. Loops auto-repeat the sound, too, which wears on you.
  • Weird usernames: It’s a spinoff of Twitter, but you can’t use your Twitter name. This is particularly annoying when trying to tag people. You’ve got to search by names, rather than usernames. Since the web version isn’t especially robust, this gets tricky if you’re trying to find someone.

Musical.ly Pros and Cons

musical.ly vs vine apps comparison

For all its strengths, Musical.ly definitely comes with some weaknesses.

Its strengths are:

  • Video creation flexibility: You can create videos from within the app or use outside ones.
  • Stories: You can string together fifteen-second clips to create ones that are up to a minute in length.
  • Filters: Nice filters and editing effects make it easier to make your video look nice.

Its weaknesses are:

  • Aimed primarily at a young crowd: If you’re an older user, you might find this app a bit youth-geared for your tastes.
  • A bit of a one trick pony: All you can do is lip sync. That’s not so bad if that’s what you’re looking for. However, if you’re after something more general, this is probably not the right choice for you.
  • Shaky Android release: Some Android phones and many tablets might find that this app behaves funny for them on the platform.

If you want to know more detailed info Musical.ly app review!

Vine and Musical.ly: The Final Comparison

For video making in general, we have to give Vine the prize. Its many features and efficient processes make it a great way to do any kind of video. However, if you’re specifically looking to create music videos, Musical.ly clearly wins with its array of filters and fun lipsyncing options. In the end, Vine gets the recommendation because it’s more general, but Musical.ly is good for its specific purpose, too.

For more help with comparisons like Musical.ly vs Vine, check out more our articles!